7 Solutions to Sheet Metal Laser Cutting Problems

Ever wondered why laser-cut sheet metal sometimes falls short of perfection? This article addresses common laser cutting problems, like burrs on workpieces and incomplete cuts, and offers practical solutions. By understanding perforation techniques and adjusting parameters, you can enhance your cutting precision and efficiency. Whether you’re troubleshooting burrs on stainless steel or optimizing perforation methods, this guide equips you with the know-how to achieve flawless results. Dive in to transform your laser cutting process from problematic to perfect.

Sheet Metal Laser Cutting

Table Of Contents

Sheet Metal Laser Cutting

Cutting perforation technology

As a general rule, drilling a small hole in the sheet metal is necessary for any hot cutting process, with only a few exceptions where cutting can start from the edge of the sheet metal.

In the past, a hole was punched using a punch mold in a laser stamping machine before the laser cutting process began.

There are two fundamental methods for laser cutting without the use of a stamping device:

Blasting perforation

During continuous laser irradiation, a localized melt pool forms in the material’s center. This molten material is rapidly ejected by the high-pressure oxygen assist gas accompanying the laser beam, resulting in the formation of a through-hole.

The dimensions of the perforation are primarily influenced by the plate thickness, laser power, and assist gas parameters. Typically, the average diameter of the blast perforation is approximately 50-60% of the plate thickness. As plate thickness increases, perforations tend to become larger and may deviate from a circular shape due to heat affected zone expansion and gravity effects on the molten material.

This method is generally not recommended for components requiring high precision or tight tolerances. It is most suitable for rapid hole creation in non-critical areas or scrap material. The process can be optimized for specific applications by adjusting laser parameters and gas flow.

It’s important to note that the oxygen pressure used during the perforation process is often similar to that used in cutting operations. This high pressure, while effective for material removal, can lead to excessive splashing and potential surface contamination around the perforation site. For applications requiring cleaner perforations, alternative assist gases like nitrogen or argon may be considered, albeit at the cost of reduced cutting speed.

Pulse perforation

A high-peak-power pulsed laser is employed to rapidly melt or vaporize localized material. Inert gases such as nitrogen or clean compressed air are utilized as auxiliary gases to mitigate hole expansion caused by exothermic oxidation. The gas pressure is maintained lower than that used in oxygen-assisted cutting. Each laser pulse generates microdroplets that are ejected, gradually penetrating the material. Consequently, perforating thick plates may require several seconds.

Upon completion of perforation, the auxiliary gas is swiftly switched to oxygen for cutting initiation. This technique results in a smaller perforation diameter and superior hole quality compared to conventional blast perforation methods. To achieve this, the laser system must not only possess higher output power but also exhibit precise spatial and temporal beam characteristics. Standard flow CO2 lasers typically fall short of these stringent requirements.

Furthermore, pulse perforation necessitates a sophisticated gas control system capable of precisely regulating gas type, pressure, and perforation duration. To ensure high-quality cuts during pulse perforation, the transition from pulsed perforation to continuous cutting must be meticulously managed.

Theoretically, cutting parameters such as focal length, nozzle standoff distance, and gas pressure can be adjusted during the acceleration period. However, in industrial applications, modulating the laser’s average power proves more practical and efficient. This can be accomplished by altering the pulse width, frequency, or a combination of both. Extensive research has demonstrated that the latter approach, simultaneously adjusting both pulse width and frequency, yields optimal results in terms of cut quality and process stability.

Analysis of the deformation of small holes cutting (small diameter and thickness)

When cutting small holes with high-power laser systems, deformation and quality issues can arise due to the energy concentration in a confined area. Traditional pulse perforation (soft puncture) techniques, while effective for less powerful systems, may lead to charring and hole distortion in high-power applications.

The primary cause of this phenomenon is the intense localization of laser energy during pulse perforation. This concentrated heat input can result in excessive material melting, vaporization, and thermal stress in the surrounding non-processing area. Consequently, the hole geometry becomes compromised, and the overall processing quality deteriorates.

To mitigate these issues in high-power laser cutting systems, it is recommended to transition from pulse perforation to blasting perforation (also known as single-pulse piercing or ordinary puncture). This method utilizes a single, high-energy pulse to rapidly create the initial hole, reducing the heat-affected zone and minimizing material distortion.

Key advantages of blasting perforation for small hole cutting with high-power lasers include:

  1. Reduced thermal input to the surrounding material
  2. Faster processing times
  3. Improved hole geometry and edge quality
  4. Minimized risk of material charring and deformation

Conversely, for lower-power laser cutting machines, pulse perforation remains the preferred method for small hole cutting. This technique offers several benefits in less powerful systems:

  1. Enhanced control over the cutting process
  2. Improved surface finish quality
  3. Reduced risk of thermal damage to delicate materials
  4. Better precision for intricate designs

Addressing Burr Formation in Low Carbon Steel Laser Cutting

When cutting low carbon steel with CO2 laser technology, burr formation can be a significant issue. Understanding the root causes and implementing appropriate solutions is crucial for achieving clean, precise cuts. Here are the primary factors contributing to burr formation and their respective remedies:

  1. Incorrect Focal Position: Conduct a focal position test and adjust the offset accordingly. Proper focus ensures optimal energy concentration at the cutting point.
  2. Insufficient Laser Power: Verify the laser generator’s functionality and check the output settings on the control panel. Adjust the power to match material thickness and cutting requirements.
  3. Suboptimal Cutting Speed: Increase the cutting speed through the machine’s control system. Finding the right balance between speed and power is essential for clean cuts.
  4. Compromised Assist Gas Quality: Ensure high-purity assist gas (typically nitrogen or oxygen) is used. Gas purity directly affects cut quality and burr formation.
  5. Focal Point Drift: Periodically perform focal point tests, especially for long cutting sessions. Adjust the offset to compensate for any drift caused by thermal effects or mechanical wear.
  6. System Instability from Extended Operation: If persistent issues occur after long runs, consider a complete system restart. This can resolve software glitches or thermal-related instabilities.

Analysis of the burr on the workpiece when cutting stainless steel and aluminum zinc plate with the laser cutter.

When cutting low-carbon steel, stainless steel, or aluminum-zinc plates with a laser cutter, burr formation is a common challenge that requires careful consideration of multiple factors. The root causes of burrs can vary depending on the material properties and cutting parameters.

For low-carbon steel, initial investigation should focus on key factors influencing burr formation, such as laser power, cutting speed, focal point position, and assist gas pressure. However, simply increasing the cutting speed is not always an effective solution, as it may compromise the laser’s ability to fully penetrate the material, especially when processing thicker plates or highly reflective materials like aluminum-zinc alloys.

In the case of aluminum-zinc plates, which are known for their high thermal conductivity and reflectivity, additional considerations are necessary. The laser’s interaction with these materials can be more complex, often requiring a fine balance between power, speed, and focal point adjustment to achieve clean cuts with minimal burr.

To optimize cutting performance and reduce burr formation, consider the following factors:

  1. Nozzle condition: A worn or damaged nozzle can disrupt gas flow, leading to inconsistent cuts and increased burr. Regular inspection and replacement of nozzles are crucial for maintaining cut quality.
  2. Motion system stability: Vibrations or instability in the guide movement can cause fluctuations in the focal point position, resulting in irregular cuts and burr formation. Ensure the machine’s motion system is properly maintained and calibrated.
  3. Assist gas selection and pressure: For stainless steel and aluminum-zinc plates, nitrogen is often preferred as an assist gas to prevent oxidation. Optimize gas pressure to effectively remove molten material without causing excessive turbulence.
  4. Focal length and position: Adjust the focal point position relative to the material surface to achieve the optimal power density for clean cuts. This may vary depending on material thickness and composition.
  5. Cutting parameters optimization: Fine-tune laser power, cutting speed, and pulse frequency (if applicable) based on material-specific requirements. Consider using parameter databases or conducting cutting trials to determine the optimal settings for each material type and thickness.
  6. Beam quality and optics condition: Ensure the laser beam is properly aligned and focused, and that all optical components are clean and in good condition to maintain consistent cutting performance.

Analysis of the incomplete cutting state of the laser.

After comprehensive analysis, the following factors have been identified as the primary contributors to unstable laser cutting processes:

  1. Improper nozzle selection relative to plate thickness:
    The nozzle geometry and diameter significantly influence the gas flow dynamics and cutting efficiency. Mismatched nozzles can lead to insufficient assist gas pressure or improper beam focusing, resulting in incomplete cuts.
  2. Excessive cutting speed:
    When the traverse rate surpasses the optimal speed for a given material and thickness, it can lead to insufficient energy density at the cutting front. This often results in dross formation, incomplete penetration, or irregular kerf width.
  3. Incorrect focal length for thicker materials:
    For cutting 5mm carbon steel plates, it is crucial to replace the standard lens with a 7.5″ focal length laser lens. This adjustment optimizes the beam focus depth, ensuring proper energy concentration throughout the material thickness.

Additional factors that may contribute to unstable processing include:

  • Assist gas pressure and type mismatch
  • Contaminated or damaged focusing optics
  • Fluctuations in laser power output
  • Improper standoff distance between the nozzle and workpiece
  • Material inconsistencies or surface contaminants

The solution for non-normal spark patterns when cutting low carbon steel

Abnormal spark patterns during the laser cutting of low carbon steel can significantly impact the quality of cut edges and overall part precision. If other cutting parameters are within normal ranges, consider the following potential causes and solutions:

  1. Nozzle degradation:
    The laser nozzle may have deteriorated or become damaged. Promptly replace the nozzle with a new one to restore optimal cutting performance. Regular nozzle inspection and replacement should be part of your preventive maintenance schedule.
  2. Cutting gas pressure adjustment:
    If immediate nozzle replacement is not feasible, a temporary solution is to increase the cutting gas pressure. This can help compensate for reduced gas flow due to nozzle wear or partial blockage. However, monitor cut quality closely, as excessive pressure may lead to other issues such as increased dross formation.
  3. Loose nozzle connection:
    The threaded connection between the nozzle and laser cutting head may have become loose. In this case:
  • Immediately halt the cutting operation to prevent further damage.
  • Carefully inspect the laser head assembly, paying particular attention to the nozzle connection.
  • If loose, securely tighten the threaded connection, ensuring proper alignment.
  • Perform a test cut to verify the issue has been resolved.
  1. Additional considerations:
  • Verify the cleanliness of the nozzle orifice and clear any obstructions.
  • Check for proper centering of the laser beam within the nozzle.
  • Ensure the focal point of the laser is correctly set for the material thickness.
  • Examine the condition of the protective lens and replace if necessary.

Selection of Puncture Points in Laser Cutting

The Working Principle of Laser Beam Cutting:

During the laser cutting process, the focused laser beam creates a localized melt pool on the material surface. As the beam continues to irradiate, it forms a depression at the center. High-pressure assist gas, coaxial with the laser beam, rapidly expels the molten material, creating a keyhole. This keyhole serves as the initial penetration point for contour cutting, analogous to a pilot hole in conventional machining.

The laser beam typically travels perpendicular to the tangent of the cut contour. Consequently, as the beam transitions from initial penetration to contour cutting, there’s a significant change in the cutting vector. Specifically, the vector rotates approximately 90°, aligning the cutting direction with the contour tangent.

This rapid vectorial shift can lead to surface quality issues at the transition point, potentially resulting in increased roughness or kerf width variations.

In standard operations where surface finish requirements are not stringent, automated CNC software generally determines puncture points. However, for applications demanding high surface quality or tight tolerances, manual intervention becomes crucial.

Manual adjustment of the puncture point involves strategically repositioning the initial penetration location. This optimization aims to minimize the impact of the vector change on the cut quality. Factors to consider include:

  1. Material properties (thickness, thermal conductivity)
  2. Laser parameters (power, frequency, pulse duration)
  3. Assist gas type and pressure
  4. Desired contour geometry

By carefully selecting the puncture point, engineers can significantly improve the overall cut quality, reducing post-processing requirements and enhancing part precision. Advanced techniques such as ramping or dimpling may also be employed to further optimize the penetration process.

It’s important to note that while manual puncture point selection can yield superior results, it requires expertise and may increase programming time. Therefore, a cost-benefit analysis should be conducted to determine when this level of optimization is warranted.

Don't forget, sharing is caring! : )
Shane
Author

Shane

Founder of MachineMFG

As the founder of MachineMFG, I have dedicated over a decade of my career to the metalworking industry. My extensive experience has allowed me to become an expert in the fields of sheet metal fabrication, machining, mechanical engineering, and machine tools for metals. I am constantly thinking, reading, and writing about these subjects, constantly striving to stay at the forefront of my field. Let my knowledge and expertise be an asset to your business.

You May Also Like
We picked them just for you. Keep reading and learn more!
Factors Affecting Laser Cutting Quality

9 Key Factors That Impact Laser Cutting Quality

Ever wondered how precision in laser cutting is achieved? This article explores the crucial factors influencing laser cutting quality, such as nozzle condition, focus position, and auxiliary gas pressure. By…

Metal Laser Cutting Machine: The Basic Guide

Imagine a machine that can slice through metal with the precision of a surgeon's scalpel. Metal laser cutting machines offer this capability, transforming how industries work with metals. This article…
MachineMFG
Take your business to the next level
Subscribe to our newsletter
The latest news, articles, and resources, sent to your inbox weekly.
© 2024. All rights reserved.

Contact Us

You will get our reply within 24 hours.